15 Best Shake Shack Secret Menu Items To Order in 2025

Shake Shack is loved for its juicy burgers and tempting shakes, but did you know there’s also a Shake Shack secret menu that can take tempting to mindblowing? While the official menu boasts an impressive list of tasty items, the Shake Shack secret menu takes tried-and-true favorites to a whole new level.

Of course, you won’t find these Shake Shack secret menu items listed anywhere on their website or inside the restaurant. That’s why we did some digging to see what hidden gems Shake Shack devotees have secretly been hiding. Now, the secret’s out and you’re about to be blown out of the water with the ingenious concoctions that we’re about to share. Enjoy this list of the 15 best Shake Shack secret menu items and prepare to find your new favorite order. 

 Jump to Section

• Does Shake Shack Have a Secret Menu?
• Shake Shack Burger Secret Menu Items
• Shake Shack Hot Dog Secret Menu Items
• Other Shake Shack Secret Menu Items

Does Shake Shack Have a Secret Menu?

Yes, Shake Shack has a secret menu. However, it’s not an official menu but rather one created by lovers of the fast food chain. Raving fans have come up with an array of creative ways to tweak the Shake Shack official menu and instead of keeping it to themselves, have shared the dishes across social media and internet forums for all to enjoy. 

If you want to get in on the action, all you need to know is how to customize regular menu items to turn them into hidden menu gems. Once you have the customizations, which we cover below, remember to explain them thoroughly to staff to ensure you get your order just how you want it. 

Shake Shack Burger Secret Menu Items 

1. Shake Shack Quad Burger

This item on the Shake Shack secret menu takes protein to another level! It may not be the best choice for health-conscious diners, but it’s an excellent choice for extreme carnivores. If you feel adventurous and hungry, ask for the Quad Burger and you’ll get four times the meat piled high between two buns.

2. Peanut Butter and Bacon SmokeShack

The Peanut Butter and Bacon SmokeShack is likely the most well-known Shake Shack secret menu item and also the most intriguing. Who would have thought that peanut butter and bacon would go together as a mouthwatering flavor combo? This treat was actually on the official menu for one weekend only and it must have gained the love of many because it stuck around as an off-menu must-have.

To enjoy this sweet and savory creation, simply order the standard SmokeShack Burger, which comes with applewood smoked bacon, cheese and chopped cherry peppers. Then ask for a side of their famous peanut butter sauce. Drizzle to your liking.

3. Shack-Cago Burger

The Shack-Cago Burger is a spin-off of the official Shack-Cago Dog. The hot dog version features a frankfurter topped with tomatoes, pickles, onions, peppers and cucumbers — but who said you can’t have the same fresh toppings in a burger? Simply ask for the hot dog to be replaced with a beef patty and you’ve got yourself a Shack-Cago Burger! If the staff at Shake Shack look at you funny when you request this, simply order a Shack-Cargo Dog and a hamburger and transfer the toppings.

4. Protein-Style Burger

If you want to skip the carbs and up the protein, the Protein Style Burger has become a ‘not so secret’ Shake Shack secret menu hack that’s fairly easy to obtain. Instead of receiving your sandwich in a potato bun, it will come wrapped in a light and crispy lettuce leaf. This can be done upon request with any menu item and is known by name as the Protein-Style option. 

5. Bunless Shack Burger

Similar to the Protein-Style Burger, the Bunless Shack Burger is another good choice on the Shake Shack secret menu for carb-curbing diners. It comes with all the goodness inside a typical burger, minus the bun. It’s served almost like a hamburger salad. Just ask for the Bunless Shack Burger and your request will be granted.  

Shake Shack Hot Dog Secret Menu Items 

6. Cheese Dog

Did you know Shake Shack began its venture as a hot dog stand before it became famous for its delicious burgers? This not-so-secret item on the Shake Shack secret menu is for those who want something simple. Sometimes all you need is cheese and all you have to do is ask for it on your hot dog. The end result is a simple and yummy treat that many are surprised isn’t on the regular menu. 

7. Garden Dog

For veggie-loving fans, this Shake Shack secret menu alternative gives you the best of both worlds — all your favorite hot dog toppings, minus the hot dog that’s replaced with a crunchy and zesty pickle for a refreshing and light meal. To order, simply ask for the meat to be replaced with a pickle. 

Other Shake Shack Secret Menu Items 

8. BLT

Sometimes, you’ll be craving the classic taste of a BLT and at Shake Shack, you can have it. This item is sometimes on the official menu. However, if it isn’t when you visit Shake Shack, you can still get one via the hidden menu. Just request a BLT from the Shake Shack secret menu by name and you’ll receive crispy bacon and lettuce topped with juicy tomato in between a sliced potato bun.  

9. Ice Cream Sandwich

Do you have a sweet tooth? Maybe you already had a meal and now you want dessert? This Shake Shack secret menu item is interesting and super easy to request. Choose from a variety of frozen custard flavors and ask for a scoop to be smooshed between a sliced potato bun. The saltiness of the bun combined with the sweet ice cream creates a harmonious symphony of delight for your tastebuds.

10. Spicy Fries

You can hack the Shake Shack official menu by ordering cheese fries topped with cherry peppers and then you have a Shake Shack secret menu item with a kick! Make it extra zesty by requesting a side of Shake Shack sauce. 

11. Topped Fries

The wonderful thing about Shake Shack is that their menu offers almost limitless customization, and that means you can apply this to almost anything on the official menu. One of the most popular customizations is adorning their crispy, crinkle-cut fries with virtually any topping they have. Think bacon bits, tomatoes, pickles, cheese and sauce — no matter how you like your loaded fries, you can probably get the toppings you desire at Shake Shack. 

12. Grilled Cheese and Bacon

Most Shake Shack establishments will let you order this simple, cheesy delicacy by its name alone. However, you may receive a grilled cheese with bacon on the side, so it’s always best to confirm that you would like the bacon added inside the cheese sandwich before it’s grilled. For even more customization, you can ask for a side of their peanut butter sauce for dipping. It may sound strange, but seriously, try it!

13. Shandy

It’s no secret that you can order beer at your local Shake Shack. But the Shandy is a Shake Shake secret menu miracle. Enjoy a refreshing twist on your ale when you request a mix of half beer and half lemonade. A Shandy is perfect for hot summer days when you want something a little fancy and very refreshing to pair nicely with your burger.

14. Root Beer Float

You can indulge in a sweet, creamy and fizzy treat with a Root Beer Float from the Shake Shack secret menu. The staff will serve it up with a scoop of their luxurious custard and bubbly root beer. The custard and carbonated soda make a delightful combination. If your local Shake Shack doesn’t make shakes behind the counter, you can ask for both items separately and then mix them for this magical concoction.

15. Beer Float

This Shake Shack secret menu drink is almost the same as the classic above but with an adult spin on it. Ask for your favorite local brew with a scoop of custard and then you have a float made for grown-ups. Cheers!

And there you have at least 15 amazing reasons to visit your nearest Shake Shack and see for yourself what their foodie-fanatics are drooling over. While most fast food establishments have customization options and secret menus, the Shake Shack secret menu lets you customize almost every regular menu item completely to your heart’s desire.

The sky is pretty much the limit when it comes to how much you can hack and tweak the official menu to experiment with different flavors and textures. After today, your experience at Shake Shake will be deliciously different. Which Shake Shack secret menu item will you try first?

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.