Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Flavors List: 15 Best Picks Ranked for 2025

Anybody who has found sanctuary from the summer heat in their local Cold Stone will know that the lineup of Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors has something for everybody in need of a reprieve from the sun.

Whether your palate prefers a more fruit-forward scoop, a classic cone of creamy vanilla or a controversial mix of mint and choco chip, there really is a cone at this iconic creamery for every culinarian. In fact, according to the International Dairy Foods Association, the average American enjoys approximately 20 pounds (about 4 gallons) of ice cream each year, proving just how beloved this frozen treat truly is.

Having said that, since the list of Cold Stone ice cream flavors is so long, it can be hard to narrow down the list to just one. Fortunately, we’re here to help. From rare seasonal treats that come around once a year to perennial dairy favorites, plus a few with which even plant-based diners can cool themselves, we’ve compiled a guide to the very best Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors so that you can get on with what matters most — screaming for ice cream.

• 15 Best Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Flavors
• What Flavors of Ice Cream Does Cold Stone Creamery Have?

15 Best Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Flavors

1. Silk Chocolate Almondmilk

We already mentioned that even vegan patrons can enjoy a fix of their favorite creamy treat at Cold Stone. One popular dairy-free Cold Stone ice cream flavor is Silk Chocolate Almondmilk. As the name suggests, it’s churned using dairy-free milk, imbibing the timeless flavor of chocolate to delight plant-based palates. 

However, it’s worth noting that while it does offer a lighter treat than dairy-based alternatives on the Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors list, some reviews say that it lacks the richness of other, dairy-based chocolate scoops available on the menu. Regardless, it is one of the healthiest ice creams on this list, and it makes a superb alternative for those with dietary restrictions or allergies, ensuring that everybody can enjoy a Cold Stone tonic in the summer heat. 

2. Birthday Cake Remix

Who doesn’t love birthday cake? Reminiscent of your younger years, when friends would gather and scream for you to blow out the candles, if you happened to wish back then that the menu of Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors would include birthday cake, well, congratulations! 

It’s ranked by some as one of the best on the Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors list. Why? Because its composition of cake batter ice cream, rainbow sprinkles, fudge and brownies is simply irresistible to those in search of the most decadent Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors. The only thing missing is candles, although, since it’s ice cream, that’s probably not a bad thing.

3. Boo Batter

Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors don’t get much spookier than Boo Batter. Available once a year in celebration of the Halloween season, this signature seasonal ice cream comes with a hearty, if not healthy, sprinkling of candy, all of which is mixed into the blend’s signature ink-black ice cream. 

It’s certainly one of the more eye-catching items on the Cold Stone ice cream flavors list. But is it one of the best Cold Stone ice cream flavors? That’s down to you and your taste buds to decide, but bear in mind that some reviews suggest that the ice cream itself is, in essence, the same as the brand’s cake batter blend but with food coloring. That said, when Halloween comes around and you find yourself craving candy, you’re unlikely to be disappointed by the amount that’s mixed in with it.

4. Germanchökolätekäke

“Awkward name. Awesome ice cream.” That’s how Cold Stone itself describes the next entry to this list of Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors. We’ll start with its composition — a blend of chocolate ice cream with pecans, coconut, brownie and caramel. Given its decadent make-up, it’s unsurprising that the creamery’s answer to German chocolate cake is often ranked as one of the best Cold Stone ice cream flavors. 

5. Cheesecake Fantasy

The name rather removes the need for imagination with this next Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavor. But does it live up to the name? Many would argue that it’s one of the most popular desserts on the menu.

A graham cracker crust, cheesecake-flavored ice cream and a blend of blueberries and strawberries combine to create a dessert that, if you love cheesecake, might just topple the real thing from the top of your list of favorite sweets. At the very least, it’s sure to become your new go-to on the Cold Stone ice cream flavors list.

6. Cookie Mintster

It’s time to address the topic of mint. Love it or hate it, it remains a perennial fixture on the menus of ice cream parlors around the world. Blended with cookies (Oreos, to be precise), it also makes an appearance on the menu of Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors.

But on a list of Cold Stone ice cream flavors ranked from best to worst, where does it sit? Well, those who love mint ice cream might be unsurprised to learn that it ranks among some of the very best Cold Stone flavors. Cookie connoisseurs can’t get enough of the Oreo crunch, and those whose taste buds can only take so much richness can find solace in the refreshing base of mint ice cream. Oh, and it also contains fudge. 

7. Oreo Overload

Another Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream flavor that wears its identity on its sleeve, you know what you’re getting yourself into when you order a scoop of Oreo Overload. What you may not know is that this particular flavor also enjoys a decadent dose of fudge. Perfect for those who love — and we mean love — all things sweet, reviews suggest that this pick from the Cold Stone ice cream flavors list tastes like a bowl of Oreo filling. 

8. Peanut Butter Cup Perfection

Confidently stating that it has perfected the timeless flavor of peanut butter cups, you and your taste buds will have to decide for yourselves whether or not this particular scoop lives up to its name. However, we’ll say this: if you love peanut butter, you’re going to get plenty of bang for your buck when you order this Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavor. 

Why? Well, you could hardly accuse Cold Stone of operating with a “less is more” mindset. In this case, not only does the ice cream come packed with pieces of Reese’s, but the churners also saw fit to throw in an extra dose of peanut butter, just to be sure. 

9. Berry Berry Berry Good

With so much chocolate, peanut butter and candy, your palate is probably pleading by now for something with which to cleanse it. If that’s the case, this next Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream flavor might just do the trick. As you’ve probably guessed by the name, it harnesses that natural flavor of berries. But is it “berry” good?

A sweet ice cream base is every bit as decadent as any other Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavor. What’s more, if you’re looking for a scoop that your health goals might just forgive you for, you’ll surely welcome the topping of real strawberries, raspberries and blueberries. 

10. Apple Pie A La Cold Stone

In antithesis to your mom’s go-to Sunday recipe, this version of apple pie is most definitely best served cold. French vanilla ice cream with cinnamon, a graham cracker crust, apple pie filling and caramel make for a decadent treat that’s as comforting as it is delicious. 

Reviewers of this Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavor are inclined to agree, hailing it for its use of tried-and-trusted flavors that simply do not disappoint. 

11. Our Strawberry Blonde

So, we know straight off the bat that this Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavor contains strawberries. But what else? It doubles down on your favorite red morsel with both strawberry ice cream and real, bonafide strawberries. It also throws in some graham cracker crust, caramel and an indulgent whipped topping. Sounds good?

It certainly does. Especially since reviews generally agree it's up there with the very best Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors. One even goes as far as saying “It’s like eating a strawberry milkshake”. And while Cold Stone itself describes it as “So good you’ll want to bring it home to mama,” be warned — it might just put her go-to pie recipe to shame.

12. Mud Pie Mojo

If the summer heat has left you feeling like you’ve lost your mojo, get it back with a scoop of Cold Stone’s answer to mud pie. Expect a peanut-forward flavor profile with a base of coffee ice cream. 

We know, it’s not for everybody, but it does its level best with the addition of crunchy Oreos and oh-so-decadent pieces of fudge. What’s more, roasted almonds provide an extra level of flavor and just the right amount of nutty crunch. It’s the go-to Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavor for those feeling nostalgic for childhood desserts, delivering them in a fashion that most adults simply can’t resist. 

13. Coffee Lovers Only

On a hot day, the most obvious substitution for your morning brew would be an iced coffee, right? Well, sort of. A better solution would be to order a scoop of this craving-busting Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavor. 

In it, coffee ice cream gets a generous sprinkling of crunchy roasted almonds and caramel. As if that wasn’t enough, little pieces of Heath Bar are then added to the top, forming a cone of joy that rolls your daily dose of caffeine and candy into one decadent serving.

14. Banana Caramel Crunch

Another Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavor that does what it says on the tub is Banana Caramel Crunch. As Cold Stone itself describes it, “This creation is nuts. And banana. And caramel.”

Imagine, if you will, firm, ripe bananas, crunchy almonds, sweet caramel and indulgent French vanilla ice cream. Not quite getting it? Don’t worry. This is a perennial fixture on the menu of Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors, so just order a scoop next time you’re there and you’ll be able to see what all the fuss is about. 

15. Founders’ Favorite

How could we possibly create a guide to the best Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors without at least a mention of the Founders’ Favorite? Cold Stone founders Donald and Susan Sutherland love this particular iteration of creamy magic, and it’s easy to see why. 

There’s nothing especially fancy about this particular Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavor, but then, that’s probably why it continues to command such a strong appeal to Cold Stone regulars. A base of sweet cream ice cream is topped with crunchy pecans, decadent fudge and a squeeze of caramel. If you love chocolate, the inclusion of gooey brownies makes it more chocolatey than you might expect.

What Flavors of Ice Cream Does Cold Stone Creamery Have?

The menu covers a full spectrum of flavors, from classics like strawberry, chocolate and vanilla to more daring concoctions like birthday cake, apple pie, peanut butter cup and even coffee. What’s more, the menu of Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors can also be customized with an endless choice of candies, fruits, berries and other indulgent adornments.

Besides the incredible array of Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors, you can also select from a tasty range of frozen yogurts. And if you have dietary restrictions or allergies, the brand’s Silk Chocolate ice cream, made from almond milk, provides a delicious and dairy-free alternative.

The creamery even offers a range of fresh and fruity sorbets that are tough to beat on a hot summer’s day. Add to all of this a list of shakes and smoothies, and it’s really no surprise that Cold Stone is one of the nation’s go-to sanctuaries when the temperatures start to rise. 

Does Cold Stone Creamery Have Sugar-Free Ice Cream?

Yes! One of the most popular Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors for those watching what they eat is “Fit Lovin’ No Sugar”. Made with sugar-free sweet cream ice cream and topped with strawberries, blueberries and coconut, this treat is sure to kick your cravings to the curb while helping you stick to your health goals. 

Does Cold Stone Creamery Have Dairy-Free Ice Cream?

Among the list of the best Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors is Silk Chocolate. This dairy-free ice cream alternative is made from almond milk. What’s more, it’s delicious, ensuring that those with dietary restrictions or allergies don’t miss out on what has to be one of the nation’s favorite hot-weather treats. 

There you have it. While this may not be a list of Cold Stone ice cream flavors ranked from best to worst, hopefully, this guide has provided you with a short list of scoops so that you can make those decisions for yourself. 

After all, not all palates are the same. Berries might be your bag while others might prefer to cool themselves with cocoa. Whatever your personal preference, what’s certain is that with such a diverse list of Cold Stone Creamery ice cream flavors to choose from, you’re sure to find something there to satisfy your sweet tooth. 

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.