Which Brand Has the Best Brownie Mix in 2024?

Many of us love brownies, especially when they're self-made, but it can often be difficult to know which is the best brownie mix to use. When it comes to chocolate brownies, using a pre-made mix is usually cheaper than making them from scratch, but that begs the question — what is the best mix to use? Several factors will help you make the best decision when it comes to choosing the best brownie mix — namely taste, quality, ease of baking and the type of brownie you're looking for.

Ready to find out more? In this guide, we'll help you make informed choices by listing the best brownie mixes based on several criteria. Get ready to learn more about one of the most popular desserts and sweet treats in the world to help you make them with ease, all thanks to the best mixes on the market.

Jump to Section 

• 13 Best Chocolate Brownie Mixes
• What Is the Best Boxed Brownie Mix?
• Learn How To Bake the Best Brownies

13 Best Chocolate Brownie Mixes

1. Betty Crocker Brownie Mix

This is the best brownie mix for those who love a chewy and sticky brownie. There is a hint of fudge in these brownies combined with a lovely flaky crust.

The flaky texture is an indicator that this is a great brownie mix. This is a sweet brownie, so it's perfect if you are looking for a milk chocolate flavor rather than its dark chocolate counterpart.

2. Duncan Hines Brownie Mix

This is one of the best brownie mixes around if you are searching for something light and not too rich. These brownies are not as heavy as others and they also look the part with their sugary flakes. If you'd like to make a chocolate cake brownie, Duncan Hines Brownie Mix will not disappoint.

3. Ghirardelli Brownie Dark Chocolate Premium Brownie Mix

This flaky and dense mix is a wonderful treat and the best brownie mix for those who love intense dark chocolate flavors. They don't turn out as sweet as most brownies from other mixes, but they most certainly pack a punch with their tasty chocolate chips.

4. Krusteaz Gluten-Free Double Chocolate Brownie Mix

Krusteaz is one of the best brownie mixes for those who want a gluten-free option. In addition, they're the perfect choice for you if you love an intense double chocolate flavor. Finally, the resulting chewy and dense texture also sets the brand apart as one of the best brownie mixes.

5. 365 by Whole Foods Market Gluten-Free Brownie Mix

Like many of the other brownie mixes on this list, 365 brownies are chewy, yet have a delightful flaky crust that makes them even more enjoyable. When it comes to taste, this brownie mix does not have as much of a strong chocolate flavor and is not as sweet as other brownie mixes on this list.

6. Pillsbury Chocolate Fudge Brownie Mix

This is one of the best brownie mixes if you want a brownie which is more like a cake than a biscuit. The mix is family-sized so it is perfect for baking a large batch as gifts for friends and family, or a large gathering. The texture is light while the crust is chewy, providing a delightful contrast. The center is full of fudge, which works well with the crisp crust, but it doesn't overpower the chocolate. If you're looking to pair brownies with ice cream, this is the brand to choose.

7. King Arthur Baking Company Gluten-Free Ultimate Fudge Brownie Mix

One of the less well-known brands on this list, King Arthur’s is the best brownie mix for those who want brownies with a delightful chocolate-fudge combination. The balance it offers between a sweet taste and cake-like texture is chef's kiss. They melt effortlessly in your mouth, giving way to a sweet and slightly salty taste combination. Don't let the gluten-free aspect throw you off as this is one of the best brownie mixes for everyone with a sweet tooth.

8. Duncan Hines Dolly Parton’s Fabulously Fudgy Brownie Mix

This special brownie mix by Duncan Hines has a fantastic fudge taste and is named after none other than Dolly Parton. This is the best brownie mix if you want fudge brownies that feel, look and taste homemade. These brownies are quite chewy, so consider that when making your choice. With precise, detailed instructions, you'll have no problem creating the best brownies from a mix. 

9. Miss Jones Double Chocolate Brownie Baking Mix

This brownie mix is 100% whole grain, making it a great choice for those who want a healthier option. The texture is chewy and dense, and the taste is a sugary delight. Overall, Miss Jones ranks among the best brownie mixes as a great whole-grain choice with a satisfying (slightly more) bitter chocolate taste.

10. Simple Mills Almond Flour Brownie Baking Mix

As expected, this brownie mix has a nuttier taste due to the almond flour. These brownies are gluten-free, yet taste just as good as traditional brownies. If you're looking for a good balance between a sweet taste and chewy texture with a cake-like feel, Simple Mills is the way to go.

11. Ghirardelli Double Chocolate Premium Brownie Mix

The double chocolate option from Ghirardelli is so good that it could pass as homemade. This is the best brownie mix if you want an intense, yet very satisfying chocolate flavor. Many people favor this option due to its moist texture, making it easy to chew. With the addition of chocolate chips in this mix, you'll soon realize why Ghiradelli is one of the most well-known brownie mix brands.

12. White Lily Chocolate Fudge Brownie Mix

An iconic brand in the South of the U.S., White Lily’s flour-making expertise is to be appreciated in this brownie mix. You can look forward to a good balance between the cake and sweet flavors. These brownies are considered tough rather than soft, so if that’s what you prefer, this is the best brownie mix for you.

13. Kodiak Cakes Protein-Packed Brownie Mix

This is another whole-grain brownie mix full of goodness. Packed with protein, these brownies are fantastic if you are searching for a slightly healthier option. This might not be the best brownie mix for an intense chocolate taste, but the chewy and delightfully dense nature makes it a good choice if you're looking for something less rich, but equally as delicious.

What Is the Best Boxed Brownie Mix?

Ready for the moment of truth? It's time to share our opinion on the best brownie mix based on different categories. All the brands on this list are great in their own right, but certain qualities stand out more than others. 

Easiest To Bake

If you want the best brownie mix with very detailed instructions based on a high level of care, then Duncan Hines Dolly Parton’s Fabulously Fudgy Brownie Mix is a great choice. You should be able to whip up a batch of delicious brownies with absolute ease when following the thorough steps. 

Best Taste

This is a tough decision and arguably the most important. However, Ghirardelli Double Chocolate Premium Brownie Mix is the best brownie mix for taste because of its rich and delicious chocolate flavor. The taste has been described as 'intense,' yet very satisfying as it melts in your mouth.

Best Texture

Ghirardelli Brownie Dark Chocolate Premium Brownie Mix and the Pillsbury Chocolate Fudge Brownie Mix are both at the top of the list for best brownie mix in terms of texture. Pillsbury’s has a gorgeous light and chewy crust texture, which is simply delightful to eat. Ghirardelli’s, on the other hand, makes its way to the top of the list because of its flaky, yet dense feel. The chocolate chips also make this a must-try brownie mix.

Healthiest Brownie Mix

Kodiak’s protein-heavy brownie mix is the best brownie mix if you're going for a relatively healthy choice. You will, however, make a slight compromise on taste compared to the brownie mixes at the top of the taste list. Miss Jones' mix is also a great option for healthier brownies due to the 100% whole grain factor.

What Is the Best Gluten-Free Brownie Mix?

Simple Mills, Krusteaz and King Arthur’s brownie mixes are in contention for the best brownie mix without gluten. Simple Mills’ mix is set apart in its almond taste, while Krusteaz’s is a great choice for those who want gluten-free brownies with an intense chocolate flavor and chewy texture.

But, it is King Arthur’s brownies that must take center stage here for their fabulous fudge-chocolate combination, and the way they are balanced brilliantly between sweet and cake-like. If you want the best brownies from a mix without the worry of gluten, King Arthur is a must-try.

Learn How To Bake the Best Brownies

Through online cooking classes, you can master key baking techniques required to make homemade brownies, with or without the best brownie mix. An expert chef will guide you through the class every step of the way, helping you to become a connoisseur yourself. Before you know it, you'll have learned how to make some of the most popular desserts and other foods, perfect for all gatherings and occasions.

What makes the best chocolate brownie mix depends on what you value most in these delicacies. Now that you're more clued up on factors such as ease of making, texture, flavor and health, you can make a more informed choice. Once you've picked out the best brownie mix, don't forget to share with friends, family and colleagues.

Quick tip: they'll work well as gifts for bakers, especially with your newfound knowledge.

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.