How To Thicken Pasta Sauce

Learning how to thicken pasta sauce can elevate your homemade dishes to restaurant-quality perfection and help you avoid kitchen mishaps. If you've ever found yourself with a watery sauce that just won't cling to your pasta, unlocking the key to how to thicken up pasta sauce can make a world of difference in your culinary creations.

But how do you thicken pasta sauce? Luckily, it's quite easy and often involves using ingredients you'll already have in your kitchen. To help you perfect the technique, this guide covers various methods and ingredients to use to thicken pasta sauce effortlessly.

From classic techniques like reducing the sauce to using starches and adding dairy, you'll discover the best ways to achieve a rich, velvety texture every time. Read on to transform your pasta dishes and impress your family and friends with your newfound skills.

 Jump to Section

• Why Is My Pasta Sauce Watery?
• Why Does Pasta Sauce Need To Be Thick?
• How To Make Pasta Sauce Thicker

Why Is My Pasta Sauce Watery?

A pasta sauce can turn out watery for several reasons. Understanding these reasons can help you effectively address the issue and know how to thicken pasta sauce so that it perfectly complements all different types of pasta. 

Use of Tomatoes

One common reason why a pasta sauce may be watery is due to the use of canned tomatoes or fresh tomatoes with high water content. All types of tomatoes release a lot of liquid during cooking, resulting in a sauce that lacks the desired thickness. Additionally, if the sauce is not cooked long enough, the excess water won't have time to evaporate, leaving the sauce runny and less flavorful.

Excess Broth or Wine

Another reason why your sauce may have too much liquid is because you’ve added too much broth or wine and haven’t given it sufficient time to reduce. Similarly, not using enough thickening agents like tomato paste, flour or cornstarch can result in a sauce that doesn't cling well to the pasta. Starchy pasta water can also be a helpful tool in learning how to thicken pasta sauce, but adding too much water or not letting the starch concentrate can get the opposite desired result and leave the sauce thin.

Cooking of the Pasta

Lastly, the type of pasta used and how it's cooked can affect the sauce's consistency. Overcooked pasta releases more starch, which can initially help thicken the sauce, but if there's too much water in the cooking process, it can dilute the sauce instead. On the other hand, undercooked pasta won't release enough starch to help thicken the sauce. To avoid a watery sauce, ensure the pasta is cooked al dente and drained well before combining it with the sauce.

Why Does Pasta Sauce Need To Be Thick?

Having a thick pasta sauce offers several culinary benefits. A thicker sauce sticks better to the pasta, ensuring each bite is coated with rich, flavorful goodness. This enhances the taste and texture of the dish, making it more enjoyable. 

Mastering how to thicken pasta sauce also allows you to create a more visually appealing meal, as a thicker sauce clings to the pasta rather than pooling at the bottom of the plate, which looks much more appetizing. Additionally, a well-thickened sauce can better hold and distribute ingredients like herbs, spices and chunks of vegetables or meat, providing a more balanced and harmonious flavor profile throughout the dish.

Moreover, a thick pasta sauce contributes to the satisfaction of the meal. It provides a heartier texture that can make the dish feel more substantial and comforting. By learning how to thicken pasta sauce, you can also control the moisture level in the dish, ensuring the sauce thickens to a point that complements the pasta perfectly, enhancing the entire pasta-eating experience. 

How To Make Pasta Sauce Thicker

1. Simmer the Sauce

One of the simplest ways to thicken pasta sauce is by simmering the sauce until it reaches a thick consistency. This method involves cooking the sauce over low to medium heat for an extended period, allowing excess water to evaporate. As the liquid reduces, the sauce becomes thicker and more concentrated in flavor. 

This technique is particularly effective for tomato-based sauces, where prolonged cooking not only thickens the sauce but also enhances the depth of its flavors. To do this, bring the sauce to a gentle simmer, stirring occasionally to prevent sticking or burning until it reaches your desired consistency.

2. Add Tomato Paste 

Adding tomato paste is an excellent method to try if you’re wondering how to thicken pasta sauce. Tomato paste is highly concentrated and provides both body and flavor. To use this technique, stir one or two tablespoons of tomato paste into your simmering sauce and continue to cook for at least a few minutes. 

The paste will quickly integrate, giving the sauce a thicker texture and a richer, more intense tomato flavor. This method is ideal for any tomato-based pasta sauce, from spicy marinara sauce to sugo Italian tomato sauce.

3. Reduce Broth

If you’ve added too much and want to know how to thicken pasta sauce that has excess broth, reducing it over low to medium heat is your best bet to reduce the liquid content. By simmering the sauce over low to medium heat, you allow the excess liquid to evaporate, concentrating the flavors and thickening the sauce naturally. This method is also useful if you have added too much wine to a pasta sauce.

4. Mix in Cheese

Grated cheeses, such as Parmesan, pecorino or cheddar, melt smoothly into sauces, adding body and richness while also thickening the dish. This method for thickening pasta sauce works best for cream-based dishes but could be used for tomato or other vegetable sauces if you’re willing to change the texture and taste slightly.

To thicken sauce with cheese, simply stir in small amounts of cheese over low heat, allowing each addition to fully melt before adding more. This method not only thickens the sauce but also adds a creamy, cheesy flavor, perfect for dishes like one pot mac and cheese.

5. Stir in a Cornstarch Slurry

If you want to know how to thicken pasta sauce, finding out what cornstarch slurry is will help you out a lot! Cornstarch slurry is a mixture of equal parts cornstarch and cold water which are mixed until smooth. This mix is then gradually added to your simmering sauce while stirring constantly. 

The sauce will begin to thicken as the cornstarch gelatinizes, typically within a few minutes. This method allows you to control the thickness of the sauce. It’s also perfect for achieving a smooth, glossy texture because adding cornstarch directly to the sauce will result in lumps occurring. Cornstarch slurry is a top thickening agent for both tomato and cream-based sauces. 

6. Mix in Flour Slurry 

This next idea for those wondering how to thicken a pasta sauce is similar to the last, just with slightly different ingredients. A flour slurry sees flour instead of cornstarch mixed with water (often boiling water) to create a paste that is then stirred into your sauce that needs thickening. 

Like cornstarch slurry, this mixture will thicken the sauce without leaving lumps. Do note that flour slurry works best with cream-based sauces or those that were started with a roux instead of tomato or very light sauces.  

7. Use a Roux

A roux, made from equal parts flour and fat, such as butter, is a classic thickening agent for cream-based sauces. To thicken pasta sauce with a roux, melt butter in a pan over medium heat and whisk in the flour until it forms a smooth paste. 

Then, gradually whisk this roux into your sauce (or gradually add your sauce to the pan with the roux), continuing to cook until the sauce thickens. This method not only adds thickness but also imparts a rich, buttery flavor, making it ideal for thickening creamy sauces like keto alfredo sauce or béchamel sauce.

8. Combine With Egg Yolks

Whisked egg yolks can be a useful ingredient to turn to when mastering how to thicken pasta sauce. To avoid curdling, temper the egg yolks by gradually mixing a small amount of hot sauce into them before adding the mixture back into the pan. Heat the sauce gently while stirring continuously until it thickens. This technique adds a luxurious, silky texture to sauces and is ideal for dishes like carbonara.

9. Incorporate Mashed Vegetables

Puréeing vegetables, such as carrots or cauliflower, and incorporating them into the sauce can effectively thicken it while adding nutrients and flavor. To do this, cook the vegetables until soft, then blend them into a smooth purée. Stir the purée into the sauce and simmer until well combined. 

This method works well when learning how to thicken pasta sauce for both tomato and cream-based sauces. However, do note that the taste and texture of the original dish will likely be altered when using mashed vegetables as a thickening agent.

10. Add Breadcrumbs 

Wondering how to thicken pasta sauce using breadcrumbs? It may sound odd, but adding breadcrumbs to your sauce can thicken the sauce and add a unique texture. This kitchen hack works because breadcrumbs will absorb excess liquid while also adding body to the sauce. 

Start with a small amount of breadcrumbs, stirring them into the sauce and allowing it to simmer for a few minutes. The breadcrumbs will swell and thicken the sauce without altering its flavor significantly. This method is especially useful for meat sauces like ragù, where the breadcrumbs can also help bind the meat and sauce together.

11. Melt in Butter

Swirling in cold butter at the end of cooking can thicken and enrich a sauce, especially cream-based ones. If you want to know how to thicken pasta sauce with butter, simply add small cubes of cold butter to the hot sauce, one at a time, and stir continuously until each piece is fully melted and incorporated. This technique, known as monter au beurre, creates a glossy finish and rich flavor while also thickening your pasta sauce.

12. Stir in Heavy Cream

Another excellent option for thickening cream and cheese-based pasta sauces is adding heavy cream. Whether your sauce has cream in it already or not, adding this fat-heavy ingredient should thicken the sauce and reduce the amount of water in it, resulting in a silky smooth sauce that sticks perfectly to pasta. 

Ensure you add the cream bit by bit to avoid overpowering the flavor of the sauce. If you don’t have heavy cream, there are quite a few heavy cream substitutes that will also help to thicken your pasta sauce.

Learning how to thicken pasta sauce can transform your homemade dishes from good to gourmet. Whether you prefer traditional methods, such as simmering and adding tomato paste, or more innovative approaches like incorporating breadcrumbs or blended vegetables, achieving the perfect sauce consistency is within your reach. By understanding how to thicken pasta sauce effectively, you can ensure your dishes are always rich, flavorful and perfectly textured. 

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.